Judge rebukes LSU, Louisiana AG for accusations in SEC case | LSU

A federal judge in Alabama and Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill found themselves at odds Wednesday over claims that the Southeastern Conference “hallucinated” citations in its lawsuit against LSU, which the judge wanted the LSU attorneys to apologize for.

Murrill refused.

“We cannot apologize for zealous representation,” Murrill submitted to the court Wednesday afternoon.

That morning, U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon admonished the LSU defense team for alleging the SEC, which used an artificial intelligence tool called Harvey to prepare its filing, had offered citations that “appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated.”

According to a report from AL.com, an attorney representing LSU, Bruce Rogers, said in court that the filing alleging “hallucinated” citations was written by Louisiana Solicitor General Ben Aguinaga.

SEC attorneys responded to say the allegation was “baseless, inflammatory and wholly improper.” Axon, according to multiple reports, told Rogers she was “deeply disappointed” by the assertions and she wanted LSU, Murrill’s office and Rogers to email her a draft apology for her approval by 3 p.m. Wednesday.

She said she wanted news releases that were “robust” and “heartfelt,” according to ESPN.

But just after 3 p.m., Murrill submitted a letter to the court saying she heard about the judge’s request from media reports.

“Assuming that reporting is accurate, I have directed my attorneys to submit this letter on my behalf, explaining that Defendants cannot comply with this directive,” Murrill wrote.

Murrill argued that there isn’t a “serious dispute that the SEC characterized certain cited cases as standing for propositions contrary to their actual holdings.” That morning in court, Rogers said he was merely using the word “hallucinated” to say the cases referenced did not support the SEC’s arguments, not that they were “made up.”

“We’re not dressing this up, OK?” Axon told Rogers, according to ESPN. “You put the pig out there. There’s no time for you to put lipstick on it.”

Murrill said the brief previously submitted in LSU’s defense “explained that the mismatch between cited cases and characterizations could be a “hallucinat(ion)” generated by artificial intelligence, which she said “constitutes legitimate advocacy.”

“Respectfully, the Court’s directive that the State of Louisiana publish a particular message and submit to the Court’s editing of that message violates basic free speech principles,” Murrill wrote.

While Murrill said she didn’t believe the court had proper jurisdiction in the case, she asked Axon to relieve LSU’s local counsel of his duties and waive the requirement for local counsel because he is an “esteemed, highly respected attorney that should not suffer any collateral consequences of this issue.”

Axon had threatened to sanction the LSU attorneys in the future if they made a similar misstep. She allowed them to resubmit the page from their filing that referenced “hallucinated” citations, rewording it to say the SEC’s citations “actually reject” the propositions they are asserting.

“This University of Alabama alumni judge needs to quit playing SEC politics and rule on the lack of subject matter jurisdiction. It is a frivolous case that has wasted both the court’s time and the State’s,” Gov. Jeff Landry posted on X.

Wednesday’s back-and-forth was another turn in a very public saga between the school and its conference, which have been at odds since LSU coaches Lane Kiffin and Will Wade recruited athletes who previously signed with pro teams.

Kiffin decided not to roster tight end Dae’Quan Wright, who was in training camp with the Eagles and Browns, and defensive tackle Zxavian Harris, who signed with the Saints, as the SEC threatened LSU with financial penalties and expulsion from the conference.

The SEC shifted the focus of its lawsuit to Wade and the men’s basketball program because of fears that former G Leaguer RJ Luis could still be added by LSU. Murrill argued the issue was “moot” because Wade said he would follow SEC protocols and wouldn’t add the 6-foot-7 guard.

This month, Baton Rouge judge William Jorden signed an order barring the SEC from punishing LSU for rostering Luis, and LSU president Wade Rousse said Tuesday that the university would follow the court order. Luis was added to the roster shortly after.

According to ESPN, Georgia Attorney General Christopher Carr sent a letter to SEC commissioner Greg Sankey on Wednesday — his second foray into the LSU saga — saying the prospect of Luis playing for the Tigers was “an immediate issue of grave concern.”

“LSU’s continued contempt for the rules of the SEC — rules they have voted on and agreed to — cannot go unaddressed,” Carr wrote, according to ESPN.

He encouraged SEC leadership to sanction LSU, “up to and including expulsion.”

Kiffin was asked Wednesday during the SEC coaches teleconference if he had a reaction to Luis being rostered and the school’s ongoing legal battle.

“There’s no planet I’m touching that right now,” Kiffin said with a laugh. “I don’t know what that means.”

He added that his sports information director cracked a joke about LSU potentially having to become an independent if it were kicked out of the SEC, saying: “Maybe we’ll start to get Notre Dame’s schedule now.”

“But that was his joke,” Kiffin said. “I’m not touching that.”

#Judge #rebukes #LSU #Louisiana #accusations #SEC #case #LSU

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *