LSU alums trust Lane Kiffin. But patience isn’t infinite. | LSU

LSU football alums Marlon Favorite and Carnell Stewart talk all the time about their alma mater, because they are very invested in the subject matter.

They are Louisiana natives, Favorite from Harvey, Stewart from River Ridge. They won national titles at LSU, Favorite claiming one in 2007, Stewart earning a pair thanks to a redshirt year in 2003. They haven’t left, working together to train athletes across the state.

If they were cut open, these former LSU linemen might bleed purple and gold. But that blood is flowing with increased pressure lately, because the Tigers have just one College Football Playoff berth — albeit, a spectacular run to a 2019 title — in a dozen years.

Favorite and Stewart are like a lot of LSU fans. They want to believe Lane Kiffin is the coach who will revive a dormant SEC power. But with the Tigers sitting at 6-4, their conversations about Kiffin and his program fail to reach a definitive conclusion.

“It’s kind of like, this is his first year, he’s pointing in the right direction,” Stewart said. “Are they gonna finish in the right direction? That part, I can’t say right now.”

They have some patience because former athletes can understand the complexities of program-building and how seasons unfold. They have faith in athletic director Verge Ausberry, who has a unique background as a former LSU linebacker from 1986-90.

But the football program’s alums, many who remain in the state and are eager to link arms with their current Tigers, want to see things turn around.

They can excuse a four-loss debut, but the tenor will change if next year is the same.

“Year 1, this is what it is,” said Favorite, aka “Big Fav,” who makes frequent appearances on local radio and has his own podcast called Inside the Trenches.

“Year 2,” he added, “we might let slide with a two-loss team.”

“Year 3? They’re looking for the bread.”

Bread is in the winning

Bread, meaning the slang term for money.

Because a payoff is expected after Kiffin was hired away from Ole Miss on a $13-million-a-year salary, and a rumored $50 million was infused into LSU’s roster — just after Brian Kelly was let go with $54 million left on his contract.

Those figures aren’t easily forgotten. Nor is LSU’s success rate versus Alabama, losing 14 of the last 16 matchups after this year’s defeat. Especially since Kelly won his first LSU-Alabama contest, 32-31, over the legendary Nick Saban in 2022.

“When you don’t win them games … ,” Favorite said, letting that statement hang in the air.

Kiffin hasn’t in 2026, and it’s left room for doubt because of his 12-16 record in ranked-versus-ranked matchups. His 61% win rate in SEC games isn’t elite, though that includes a season as a 33-year-old head coach at Tennessee and his early years at Ole Miss.

He built Ole Miss into a program that advanced to the CFP semifinals, but Kiffin didn’t coach those games. He bounced to LSU in late November.

“The not-so-optimistic end is he’s never really won the big game, right?” Favorite said. “No SEC championships. His (0-6) record against Alabama. His record against other SEC teams.

“Now, in my opinion, I think just having people like Verge and Coach Ed Orgeron around is helpful. I do think Coach Kiffin has a listening ear. I do think he’s a genius of a play caller.”

There was a belief that supplying Kiffin with every resource in his debut season would result in a product closer to 2025 Ole Miss than 2025 LSU. And, statistically, there has been some progress.

The Tigers jumped from the 109th-ranked offense in college football to eighth in just one season. Their red-zone success rate, tied for 99th nationally, just hasn’t kept pace.

Failures from inside the 20-yard line — and even closer sometimes — were catastrophic in losses to Ole Miss, Kentucky and Texas, which came by a combined 10 points.

It’s not hard to envision a reality where LSU is 8-2 or 9-1, especially if Sam Leavitt doesn’t throw three interceptions, including two in the end zone, in a 22-21 loss to Texas.

“I could whip out my jimmy and piss from the 5 (yard line), and you can’t put the ball in the end zone?” said former LSU safety Tyrann Mathieu on his In The Bayou podcast. “Not just put it in, you give it to the other team? So now you’re taking points off the board?”

“Issue is it’s their first team, their first year,” he added of Kiffin. “For me, it’s football (crap).”

Most of the criticism inside the LSU-verse, aside from a few fourth-down calls, isn’t being pinned on Kiffin. Mathieu was asked point blank if he thinks Leavitt should be back next year, and he rated him as “indecisive” and, simply, “not what this offense needs.”

Ask Stewart and the former right tackle hones in on the Tigers’ offensive line, which doesn’t “attack” opponents the way LSU did back in the day.

“Let’s just say the offensive line, across the board, is kind of soft,” Stewart said. “I hate to use that word, but they’d understand it if they heard it coming from me or any other coach. We were in-your-face offensive linemen.

“When we played, the average SEC defensive line couldn’t walk up and talk crap to us because the worst thing was to get us upset.”

A fence around the state

There are quibbles some LSU alums have with Kiffin, but they are rarely schematic.

The addition of celebrities to the program’s Tiger Walk, including the likes of rapper Lil Wayne and actor Kevin Costner, has been far from universally liked.

Kiffin has reiterated the invites have been for recruiting purposes more than anything, so high schoolers come away thinking LSU is a cool place. But football purists don’t find the sideshow cool when the team isn’t winning. And they wonder if it distracts the players.

“I think he embraces a lot of the noise,” said Favorite, who played for Bill Belichick and the Patriots and wonders if Kiffin, who swore off social media ahead of this season, could benefit from canceling out even more noise.

“Once all the hoopla is over with from the Tiger Walk, then (the players) have to lock into the game — and it kind of shows on the field to me,” Stewart said. “I would say conditioning, that’s not a problem. That was a problem when Brian Kelly was there. I know that for a fact.”

Kiffin may disagree on the distraction piece, but there are signs he’s accepting of feedback. After ex-LSU running back Leonard Fournette criticized celebrities joining the Tiger Walk, because the optics were bad and celebrities hadn’t earned the right, the former No. 7 jersey wearer was invited to accompany Kiffin ahead of the Texas game.

The New Orleans native Fournette, who has his own podcast called 4th and South with fellow LSU alum Jarvis Landry, has another request of Kiffin that seems to be shared by every former LSU football player with a platform.

They want Kiffin to put a “fence” around the state of Louisiana, as Saban put it, in recruiting. Fournette went as far as to shout out Alabama quarterback commit Elijah Haven, a five-star recruit from The Dunham School, promising to pay him out of his own pocket if he agreed to stay in-state and play for LSU.

“Freshman from Louisiana, playing, making plays,” said Fournette, who was a 1,000-yard rusher in his first LSU season. “There is this big thing we’ve always believed at LSU, your top guys coming in and making an immediate impact.”

Eight of Kiffin’s 18 commits in the 2027 class are from Louisiana, including four-star quarterback Peyton Houston from Shreveport. LSU recently flipped Tulane safety commit Devin Lavalais, the cousin of former LSU All-American D-tackle Chad Lavalais.

They will add to a roster, diversified by an influx of transfers from elsewhere, that currently has just 42 players listed as natives of the state, or just under 37% of the total. LSU’s percentage of in-state talent was around 55% during the title years.

It may be easier said than done in the transfer portal era, but there’s a desire to see Kiffin, and, just as importantly, the Louisiana native Orgeron, mine a football hotbed.

“I played on 10 NFL teams,” Favorite said. “I’ve never played on a team across this entire country and didn’t at least have two or three Louisiana teammates. That’s just what it is.”

As the wideout Landry put it on his podcast, “No matter who we play, we got to kick their (butt) and that’s gotta be the standard. And that starts with recruiting Louisiana.”

Holding out hope

A couple of competitive losses to Alabama and Texas were deflating, especially since LSU inflated expectations with a 51-10 blowout of Clemson in the opener.

But the Tigers were one defensive stop short versus Texas. Long-term injuries to safety Dashawn Spears and No. 7 jersey wearers Whit Weeks and Trey’Dez Green, if they didn’t happen, could have flipped a 35-34 overtime loss at Kentucky.

Kiffin has emphasized a need to build out the “middle to bottom” of the roster through recruiting and has painted an optimistic future where the Tigers aren’t playing games close but beat the likes of Kentucky and Texas by two scores.

“Let’s give him a year to do that,” Mathieu said on his podcast. “And I think once he does that, now we could hold him a 100% accountable.”

Patience isn’t infinite.

Not anywhere in this high-stakes era of college football, but especially at a school that invests as heavily as LSU. And not with a program that has, sans 2019, been outside the playoff for more than a decade despite the state’s disproportionate output of NFL talent.

Not to mention the losses to Alabama, an SEC foe the Tigers won’t even play in 2027.

“You gotta think how the fans are thinking too,” Favorite said, referring back to Kelly’s 2022 win over Alabama and Kiffin’s loss. “So that’s what I’m hearing, you know? From a fan’s perspective, hey man, we gotta win at least these games.”

There is dissatisfaction but LSU alums like Favorite and Stewart aren’t panicking just yet. If the Tigers miss the playoff next year, in a 24-team field, their worry could increase.

But, for now, hope springs from uncertainty.

“I didn’t see four games, right?” Favorite said of LSU’s 2026 loss total. “But I do think that he’ll get better each year, and I think within that four-year (timeframe), he’s gonna win a national championship.”

“Or at least attend one,” Favorite interjected, tempering his optimism slightly. “At least attend one.”

#LSU #alums #trust #Lane #Kiffin #patience #isnt #infinite #LSU

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *