Is QB Tyler Shough regressing? If so, blame the Saints | Saints

Tyler Shough was frustrated when he rewatched his performance from last week’s loss to the Carolina Panthers. The New Orleans Saints quarterback found himself moving through his progressions too quickly, disrupted by Carolina’s decision to often drop back seven defenders and only rush with four. Other times, Shough was unhappy with his feet — he said he needed to slow down, take a beat to feel the pressure, climb the pocket and “rip it.”

Individual moments bothered him, too. The two turnovers early on. Having to settle for a field goal on the last drive.

“There were a couple of plays that I wish I had back that I felt could have made the difference,” Shough said.

Shough wasn’t the only one critical. For the first time since he took over as the Saints’ starter last year, Shough has faced real heat from national analysts and some fans. The Athletic’s Robert Mays said on his podcast that he hates “this version of Tyler Shough.” ESPN’s Ben Solak even argued the Saints could need a new quarterback for 2027. On social media, people debated whether the 27-year-old has regressed in his second year.

Has Shough actually gotten worse in Year 2? The question comes at an appropriate time. As he prepares for Sunday’s game against the Chicago Bears, Shough has nine starts under his belt this season — the same total he had as a rookie.

The numbers overall don’t reveal much of a dip compared to last year, but then again, he hasn’t necessarily taken the step forward people expected, either. More troubling, though, Shough’s recent trends suggest he is in a bit of a slump.

If he is regressing, that may say more about the Saints than Shough.

All season long, Shough has been asked to carry an offense that hasn’t been able to consistently run the ball, dealt with a rotating door of offensive linemen behind a coaching staff that’s been called predictable.

Shough isn’t without blame, of course, but it is fair to wonder whether the circumstances are finally catching up to him.

“This league is about evolution, and you’re constantly evolving and people are going to have a counter-move to you, and you have to respond,” Saints coach Kellen Moore said. “We’ve got to do that schematically, and players get to do that as well.

“Tyler’s been on a good journey. He’s going to be in a great place and going to play some good football and we’ll be rolling.”

Through nine starts this season, Shough’s stats look mostly similar to his rookie year. He’s thrown for more touchdowns (10 to 15), but his completion percentage is slightly worse (69% to 66.8%) and his passing yards are lower (2,256 to 2,173) than in his first nine starts. His passer rating has also dipped a few points (95.8 to 90.8).

But the underlying numbers are what may be cause for concern. Notably, on intermediate throws and average depth of target — Shough’s best qualities as a rookie — Shough’s frequency has plummeted.

According to Pro Football Focus, only 16% of Shough’s throws have gone between 10 and 19 yards, down from 22.6% last year. While that may not seem like a huge drop-off, Shough has gone from the 15th-most aggressive quarterback in that area last year (minimum 25 attempts) to the 27th in 2026.

Shough’s average air yards per attempt is also a full yard lower, according to Next Gen Stats, falling from 8.3 (12th) to 7.4 (25th).

The Saints need Shough to stay aggressive; he’s still highly efficient when he does let it rip. The problem seems to be that Shough, whether intentionally or not, has experienced a material shift of late.

Before the Vikings game in Week 5 (Oct. 11) — a game in which the quarterback faced a relentless 50% pressure rate — Shough’s frequency on intermediate throws was still 19.2%. Since then, the percentage has cratered to 12.3%, according to Pro Football Focus.

Only Denver’s Bo Nix and Pittsburgh’s Aaron Rodgers have been more gun-shy with those throws.

“The biggest thing when you have a young quarterback is, ‘Are they seeing it?’” Saints offensive coordinator Doug Nussmeier said. “Tyler’s seeing it. … If they’re not seeing it, that’s when you got issues. But sometimes you get sped up and the game becomes a little bit fast in your mind.

“Like we say, we want to play fast, but we don’t want to play sped up too fast. There’s a fine line there.”

And the Saints haven’t helped matters, as much as they tried with an offseason aimed at revamping the offense with the additions of running back Travis Etienne, guard David Edwards and wide receiver Jordyn Tyson.

Tyson, though, got hurt in training camp and didn’t make his debut until Nov. 8. And even with Edwards’ addition, the Saints have had significant injuries up front. Tackle Kelvin Banks was out five games with an ankle sprain. After he returned, center Erik McCoy (biceps) and tackle Taliese Fuaga (knee) got hurt and are on track to miss their second straight game.

Still, the personnel hasn’t been questioned nearly as much as the coaching. In New Orleans’ loss to the Vikings, former Saints quarterback and Fox analyst Drew Brees was bewildered on the broadcast that Moore wasn’t dialing up play-action to help Shough. Moore heard the feedback and said he needed to do better by calling it.

He hasn’t. In the four games after facing the Vikings, the Saints have a play-action rate of 14.3%— even lower than in their first five games (18.8%), according to Next Gen Stats.

But the Saints’ biggest problem is, and has been, their lack of running game. The Saints have rushed for under 100 yards in 16 of Moore’s 26 games as coach. And this season, Shough has been the Saints’ leading rusher — with only 187 yards.

Every quarterback obviously benefits from a strong running game. But it is becoming apparent that the Saints’ lack of consistency there is starting to affect Shough’s play.

According to Next Gen Stats, Shough has thrown past the sticks on just 25.5% of early downs this season, behind only Nix. This appears to be the quarterback’s way of making sure the Saints stay in reasonable down and distances, if the Saints’ run game isn’t going to do it for them.

In the two games since the bye week, Shough has started to scramble more than earlier this season. He said Moore didn’t emphasize this during the break, adding he’s just reading and reacting to the opposing defense.

The Saints ran the ball well in their win over the Cleveland Browns before crashing back to earth a week later against Carolina. Across both games, eight of Shough’s 10 scrambles came on first or second down and gained positive yardage.

Still, Shough said he doesn’t feel as if he’s compensating for the Saints’ struggles in the run.

“You’re taking what you’re given,” Shough said. “You have to be aggressive in certain moments, whenever you get those. But you’re not not going to take a profit.”

In one way, settling for check-downs could be a sign of a quarterback’s on-field maturity. Shough has lowered his sack rate in his second year, from 8.7% to 6.3%. He arguably has faced less pressure of late because he’s getting the ball out faster. Tight end Juwan Johnson said he feels Shough’s biggest improvement in Year 2 is the quarterback’s recognition.

But there is a balance between making the “right” play and playing into the opponent’s hands because the defense is dictating where the ball should go — a tug-of-war every young quarterback has to learn to manage.

Across the league, some quarterbacks haven’t let the lack of run game dictate their play. Houston’s C.J. Stroud ranks first in air yards per game, despite Houston’s 29th-ranked rushing attack. Green Bay’s Jordan Love is an MVP candidate, and the Packers average the fewest rushing yards per game since the 2000 San Diego Chargers. But those two signal-callers are in Year 4 and 7, respectively.

With 18 starts, Shough has barely played a full season.

“The good thing is a lot of times Tyler gets to experience something, goes through a challenge and then he learns from it and grows,” Moore said. “He just gets better.”

The fear, of course, is that Shough won’t progress, that the Saints’ situation ultimately prevents him from taking that leap. And if circumstances get more difficult, there’s always the outside worry that Shough will revert to bad habits that New Orleans has tried to fix.

A former NFL assistant, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss Shough’s play frankly, said many of Shough’s issues lately mirror what the quarterback displayed in college. The coach said Shough is playing like he’s “afraid to pull the trigger” because he’s worried about getting hit and is bailing on pockets as soon as they get murky.

“He kind of always escapes back and away,” the coach said. “So he ends up getting himself in more trouble.”

That’s why the Panthers’ game drew so much scrutiny. Shough looked antsy even in moments when there was no legitimate pressure, as if he had been spooked by the 34 hits (ninth-most) he had taken this season.

The pattern was especially glaring on the final drive, when he bolted from the pocket, passed up a chance to take a deep shot to Chris Olave and was late to Alvin Kamara on a check-down. He then settled for short throws to Kamara on the next two plays, leading to a 55-yard field goal.

“It sucks in retrospect to look at it,” Shough said.

Even there, the blame didn’t fall solely on Shough. Moore said he could have called plays better to move New Orleans downfield, an assessment the former NFL assistant agreed with.

Asked how he would evaluate his season overall, Shough said the Saints’ 3-6 record isn’t what he wants but that he’s learning something new about himself each game.

It is a year with highs, such as upsetting Baltimore and leading a fifth career game-winning drive against Cleveland — thanks in part to some magnificent deep throws. But the campaign has also featured new lows, hence the criticism after Carolina.

“Every single week, there’s going to be a new narrative on what’s going on in the world,” Shough said. “I really don’t care. I’ve got to continue to get better, and that’s not a secret.

“You could say the same thing about every quarterback in the NFL. We’ve all got to get better, and you continue to learn from every rep.”

#Tyler #Shough #regressing #blame #Saints #Saints

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *